Skip to main content
sealcoating

Coal Tar Sealant Bans: What Parking Lot Owners Must Know

Coal tar sealcoat holds about 1,000 times more PAHs than asphalt-based products. Minnesota, New York, Virginia and some counties now restrict it. Here is where the rules apply, who is liable and how to write a coal-tar-free spec.

Wins Parking 5 min readUpdated
On this page
  1. Why coal tar sealant is a problem
  2. Where coal tar sealant is banned
  3. Who is liable: the owner or the contractor?
  4. How to write a coal-tar-free sealcoat spec
  5. Is sealcoating still worth it?
  6. How Wins Parking handles sealcoating and pavement work
  7. Next step

Yes, in many places it is now illegal to put coal tar sealant on a parking lot. Minnesota, New York and Virginia have statewide rules, and counties such as Prince George's County, Maryland, ban it outright. If you sealcoat a lot, the safe default is an asphalt-based or other low-PAH product, plus written proof from your contractor.

Why coal tar sealant is a problem

Coal tar sealant is a black liquid made from a byproduct of coking coal. It is sprayed or squeegeed onto asphalt to make it look new and slow wear.

The issue is polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, or PAHs. Several PAHs are suspected human carcinogens and are toxic to aquatic life, according to the U.S. Geological Survey.

The numbers are large:

  • Coal-tar-based sealcoat contains more than 50,000 mg/kg of PAHs. Asphalt-based sealcoat contains about 50 mg/kg. That is roughly 1,000 times less.
  • In six central and eastern U.S. cities, the median PAH level in dust from sealcoated lots was 2,200 mg/kg. In western cities, it was 2.1 mg/kg.
  • Manufacturers recommend reapplying sealcoat every 2 to 4 years. Wear shows in high-traffic lanes within a few months.

That wear matters. As the coating breaks down, PAH-rich particles wash into storm drains and get tracked indoors. USGS reports that runoff from coal-tar-sealed pavement stays acutely toxic to small fish and water fleas even when collected more than 3 months after application (USGS Fact Sheet 2016-3017).

Where coal tar sealant is banned

Rules differ by state and county. Here are verified examples:

  • Minnesota: The sale and use of coal tar-based sealants have been illegal statewide since January 1, 2014. A state sediment study found coal tar sealants made up 67% of total PAHs in 15 metro-area stormwater ponds (Minnesota Pollution Control Agency).
  • New York: The sale ban took effect November 8, 2022. The use ban took effect November 8, 2023 (Office of the Governor).
  • Virginia: Since July 1, 2024, sellers cannot sell pavement sealant with more than 1% PAHs by weight. Old stock could not be used after July 1, 2025. A violation carries a $250 penalty (WHRO).
  • Prince George's County, Maryland: Selling, using or allowing the use of coal tar pavement products has been banned since July 1, 2015. Contractors or owners who use them face fines of up to $1,000 per day per violation (Prince George's County).

More bills keep coming. Illinois HB2487 would ban sales on October 1, 2026, and use on October 1, 2027, but it has sat in the House Rules Committee since March 2025. New Hampshire HB 1614 was sent to interim study in March 2026 and did not become law. Pending bills are not law. Check your state and city code before each job.

Who is liable: the owner or the contractor?

Do not assume the contractor carries all the risk. Prince George's County fines apply to "contractors or property owners." Its rule covers anyone who uses or permits the use of the product on a property.

That means the owner, asset manager or HOA board that signs the work order can be on the hook. A single sealcoat job on a large lot can cover tens of thousands of square feet. If a fine runs per day, the exposure adds up fast.

There is also a longer tail. PAHs collect in stormwater pond sediment. Prince George's County notes that this makes dredging and disposal expensive. Minnesota regulators say local governments that manage those ponds share that concern. If your site has a detention pond, what you put on the lot today can affect what that pond costs to clean later.

How to write a coal-tar-free sealcoat spec

A clear spec protects you even where no ban exists yet. Put these items in the contract:

  1. Name the product type. Require asphalt-emulsion or another non-coal-tar sealer. State "no coal tar, no refined tar."
  2. Set a PAH limit. Virginia's 1% by weight is a useful benchmark. Ask for a lower limit if your local rule is stricter.
  3. Require the safety data sheet (SDS). Have the contractor submit the SDS and product data sheet before work starts. Keep them in the property file.
  4. Check the labels on site. Have your manager photograph the drums or totes on the day of work.
  5. Add an indemnity clause. The contractor should cover fines and cleanup if a banned product is used.
  6. Plan for cure time. Most sealers need dry weather and time to cure before traffic. Schedule closures by section so tenants keep access.

Sealcoat is a surface treatment. It does not fix base failure, standing water or alligator cracking. Those need crack sealing, patching, drainage work or an overlay first. Sealing over failed pavement wastes the coating.

Is sealcoating still worth it?

For many lots, yes. A good sealer slows oxidation, keeps out some water and gives fresh striping a clean surface. The value depends on the pavement's condition and traffic.

The decision tree is short:

  • Pavement in good shape with fine cracks: Crack seal, then sealcoat with a low-PAH product on a 2 to 4 year cycle.
  • Wide cracks, potholes or soft spots: Repair first. Sealcoat comes last.
  • Widespread failure or poor drainage: Plan a mill and overlay or full reconstruction. Fix grades and drainage in the same project.

In snow country, the timing matters even more. Plows, chains and deicers wear coatings faster. Plan sealcoat for warm, dry months, and pair it with a crack-seal program so water does not freeze in the base. See our parking lot maintenance schedule and our guide to paving materials for the full cycle.

How Wins Parking handles sealcoating and pavement work

Wins Parking is a family-owned company that has been in the Vail Valley since 2016. We are Rocky Mountain based and serve owners across the country with design, build and manage teams. Wins Design & Build is our construction division.

On a sealcoat or pavement project, we:

  • Assess the lot. We map cracks, failed areas, drainage problems and ADA stalls before we price any coating.
  • Write the spec. We specify non-coal-tar sealers and collect the SDS and product data for your file.
  • Sequence the work. We phase closures so tenants, guests and fleets keep access. Crack sealing, patching, sealcoat and striping happen in the right order.
  • Fix what sealcoat cannot. When the problem is drainage or base failure, our design-build team handles regrading, paving and snow-storage planning.
  • Manage the lot after. Our parking management services team can run permits, enforcement and LPR cameras on the finished lot.

You can see the kinds of projects we take on in our case studies.

Next step

Planning a sealcoat, repair or repave? Call (970) 279-1744 or start at https://winsparking.com/contact. We will review your lot, check the local rules and give you a coal-tar-free plan.

Frequently asked questions

Is coal tar sealant banned nationwide?

No. There is no federal ban. Restrictions come from states, counties and cities, such as Minnesota, New York, Virginia and Prince George's County, Maryland. Check your state and local code before each sealcoat job.

Can a property owner be fined if the contractor used coal tar sealant?

Yes, in some places. Prince George's County, Maryland, applies fines of up to $1,000 per day to contractors or property owners who use or permit the use of coal tar pavement products.

What should I use instead of coal tar sealant?

Asphalt-based sealers are the common alternative. USGS data show they contain about 50 mg/kg of PAHs, compared with more than 50,000 mg/kg in coal-tar-based products.

How do I prove my sealcoat is coal-tar-free?

Require the contractor to submit the safety data sheet and product data sheet before work, photograph the product labels on site, and keep the records in the property file.

How often should a parking lot be sealcoated?

Manufacturers recommend every 2 to 4 years, according to USGS. Heavy traffic, plows and deicers can wear coatings faster, so inspect the lot each year.

Sources

  1. pubs.usgs.gov
  2. pubs.usgs.gov
  3. pubs.usgs.gov
  4. pca.state.mn.us
  5. governor.ny.gov
  6. whro.org
  7. princegeorgescountymd.gov
  8. ilga.gov
  9. citizenscount.org

How Wins Parking can help

Ready to Unlock Your Parking Revenue?

Request a proposal. Tell us about your property and we'll show you what's possible.

Your mobile information will not be sold or shared with third parties for promotional or marketing purposes.

Privacy Policy | Terms

Prefer to talk? Call or text 877-713-WINS (877) 713-9467 or (970) 279-1744